Why Great Volleying Has Never Guaranteed Grand Slam Success

Part 1 of a two-part series on net play and modern match reality.

For decades, tennis players have been told a simple story ….
“If you want to become a champion, you must be great at the net.”

It sounds logical.
It sounds elegant.
And it sounds completely convincing.

But tennis history …. real match history, not highlight reels …. tells a very different story.


The Myth That Refuses to Die

Volleying has always been associated with ….

  • Skill
  • Courage
  • “Complete tennis”
  • Classical beauty

Because of this, many players grow up believing that net play is the ultimate separator between good players and champions.

This belief has damaged more careers than it has helped.

Not because volleying is unimportant ….
but because volleying has never been the deciding factor at the highest level.


What Tennis History Quietly Shows Us

If great volleying alone created champions, then tennis history would look very different.

Some of the cleanest, most natural volleyers the game has ever seen ….

  • Had textbook serve-and-volley skills
  • Possessed beautiful touch and instincts
  • Finished points effortlessly at the net

Yet many of them ….

  • Never won a Grand Slam
  • Or had only brief success
  • Or were exposed over long matches

Why?

Because matches were not decided at the net.
They were decided before the net ever came into play.


The Real Battleground of Modern Tennis

Modern tennis is not decided by ….

  • Who volleys better
  • Who looks more stylish
  • Who finishes prettier points

Modern tennis is decided by ….

  • Depth control
  • Quality of return
  • Rally tolerance
  • Movement under pressure
  • Mental patience

The baseline is no longer a waiting area.
It is the command center of the match.


Why Even Great Volleyers Struggled at the Top

Even the best volleyers faced unavoidable realities ….

  • Passing shots improved dramatically
  • Returns became more aggressive
  • Heavy topspin pushed them back
  • Neutral net approaches were punished

Volleying became a reaction skill, not a domination skill.

And at the highest level, reaction is never enough.


The 67% Net-Point Myth …. What the Data Really Means

Modern match analytics, often highlight an important statistic ….

  • Points won at the net: ~63–67%
  • Points won from the baseline: ~45–48%

At first glance, this seems to suggest that net play is more effective than baseline play.

The data itself is correct.
The interpretation is where mistakes happen.


Why Net Points Show a Higher Win Percentage

Net points do not show a higher win percentage because volleying is superior.

They show a higher win percentage because players usually come to the net only after they have already won the baseline battle.

In most professional matches, a net point begins when ….

  • The opponent is stretched or late
  • The ball is short or floating
  • The court is already open
  • The rally advantage is already established

The volley does not create the advantage.
It collects the reward.


What the Data Does Not Say

The data does not say ….

  • Rush the net early
  • Serve-and-volley more
  • Volley better to win more

In fact, the same analytics consistently show ….

  • Neutral-ball net approaches lose points
  • Forced approaches fail under pressure
  • Most volley errors come from poor decisions, not poor technique

The problem is not volleying.
The problem is approaching without earning the advantage.


Baseline Tennis Is the Engine …. Net Play Is the Finish

Baseline play:

  • Builds pressure
  • Steals time
  • Breaks legs
  • Breaks patience

Only after this work is done does the net become a high-percentage option.

That is why net points show higher success rates …. not because net play dominates,
but because dominance was already achieved from the baseline.


A Hard Truth Most Players Don’t Like Hearing

You don’t win matches at the net.
You earn the right to finish at the net.

Ignoring this sequence leads to ….

  • Forced approaches
  • Low-percentage volleys
  • Momentum loss
  • Emotional frustration

Volleying without advantage is not bravery.
It is misjudgment.


What High-Percentage Tennis Actually Looks Like

At the elite level ….

  • Net approaches are earned, not attempted
  • Volleys are simple, not artistic
  • Finishes are inevitable, not rushed

The best players don’t look aggressive.
They apply pressure quietly until the opponent cracks.


Why This Matters for Serious Players Today

Many players stall their progress by ….

  • Chasing “complete tennis” too early
  • Forcing net play to look aggressive
  • Copying highlights instead of match patterns

What actually builds winners is ….

  • Mastery of neutral balls
  • Comfort in long rallies
  • Physical and mental endurance
  • Clear decision-making

Volleying is a support skill, never the foundation.


A Final Word

Tennis has never rewarded beauty in isolation.
It rewards control before courage.

Players who dominate from the baseline decide when the point ends.
Players who rush the net hope it ends quickly.

That difference …. between deciding and hoping …. is the difference between admiration and trophies.


Stats Clarification Box (For Parents & Juniors)

“Why do net points show a higher win percentage?”

  • Net points are usually played after the opponent is already under pressure
  • Players come forward when the ball is short or weak
  • The rally advantage is already established

👉 This does NOT mean ….

  • Net play is better than baseline play
  • Players should rush the net early

👉 It means ….

  • First win the rally from the baseline
  • Then finish at the net when it is easy

Sequence matters more than style.


One Line to Remember

History is full of beautiful volleyers without trophies.
It is ruled by players who first controlled the baseline.

Continued in Part 2: Why Net Play Is a Reward …. Not a Strategy

About the Author

Alex Gomes is a high-performance tennis coach and mentor with decades of on-court experience working with serious junior and competitive players.

His coaching philosophy, The Gomesee Way, focuses on understanding why improvement stalls, how training disconnects from match performance, and how players regain clarity under pressure.

This platform reflects lived court-side observation …. not borrowed theory.

Comments

One response to “Why Great Volleying Has Never Guaranteed Grand Slam Success”

  1. yogesh joshi Avatar
    yogesh joshi

    Yes sir
    Very well said and explained in depth, it shows how much you have experienced and still do depth studies on Tennis… I like most things is ,the way is explaining it is easy to understand and improve in game…
    Great 💪🏻👍🏻🫡
    Thank you 🙏🏻 sir

Leave a Reply to yogesh joshi Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *